They failed hilariously barely knocking the white ring around my heart down, so I just pulled out my dynamite arrow and one shot them. They got off their horse, waved at me then pulled out 2 sawed off shotguns as I was in the animation of waving back and then proceeded to unload all shells into me My most recent experience was this idiot posse leader who came trotting up to me in Blackwater wearing all bright (and very ugly) pink lol